Mythic+ Group Finder and PUG Guide for Midnight Season 2
Most Mythic+ keys in Midnight are run with strangers from Group Finder, and pugging all the way to Keystone Master and beyond is completely normal. What separates players who get invited from those who sit in the queue is how they apply, which keys they pick and how they behave once the timer starts. This guide covers the Group Finder settings in patch 12.1.5, the rating groups expect for each key level, how to list and fill your own key, and the etiquette that keeps a PUG together until the last boss.
PUG, Guild or Premade: Which Is Better for Rating
PUGs are the fastest way to play any time you want, and every rating milestone up to Keystone Legend is reached by many players without a fixed group. Their weakness is consistency: a new group has no shared route and no plan for the hardest pulls, and some leave after the first wipe. A guild or a static group times higher keys more often because everyone knows the route and the cooldown plan. A good path is to pug until your keys feel stable, then keep the players you liked in your friends list and build a regular group from them.
How to Get Invited to Mythic+ Groups
Group leaders see a lot of applicants for every key, and most decide in a few seconds. Your rating, your best run in that dungeon and your item level are what they check first.
Apply to the Right Keys
Apply to keys at or just above the level you have already timed in that dungeon. A leader listing a +10 rarely invites someone whose best run in that dungeon is a +6. A useful benchmark is the rating you would have after timing every dungeon at one level, because groups often look for roughly that number:
| Key level | Rating after timing all 8 dungeons at this level |
|---|---|
| +5 | 1,720 |
| +7 | 2,080 |
| +10 | 2,560 |
| +12 | 2,920 |
| +13 | 3,040 |
| +15 | 3,280 |
Our Midnight Season 2 Mythic+ rating guide has the score for every key level.
Write a Short Application Note
The note field is your only chance to stand out. Mention your best time in that dungeon, that you know the route, or what you bring: a battle resurrection, Bloodlust, a dispel or extra interrupts. Keep it to one line.
Why Groups Decline You
The usual reasons are a rating well below the key, no timed run in that dungeon, an item level far below the other applicants, or the Keystone Deserter flag. That flag appears when you leave keys without using the /abandon vote, and it disappears as you complete keys normally.
Which Roles and Specs Get Invited Fastest
Tanks and healers get invited almost instantly, because every group needs exactly one of each. Among damage dealers, specs that bring something the group lacks have the edge, such as Bloodlust, a battle resurrection or a strong interrupt. In Season 2 the strongest tanks are Blood Death Knight and Guardian Druid, the strongest healers Holy Paladin and Restoration Shaman, and Arms Warrior, Elemental Shaman, Subtlety Rogue and Arcane Mage lead the damage dealers. Our best Mythic+ comps guide shows how they fit together.
How to List Your Own Key in Group Finder
Running your own key is the most reliable way to progress, because you choose the dungeon and the group. Press I, open Premade Groups, choose Dungeons and then Start a Group. Pick the dungeon and key level, then fill in the listing.
Group Finder Settings in Patch 12.1.5
These are the fields you set before you press List Group:
- Playstyle (required): Learning, Relaxed, Competitive or Carry Offered. Choose Learning or Relaxed for a key you are still learning, and Competitive only when you plan to push for time.
- Minimum Mythic+ rating: players below it don't see your listing. You can't set it above your own rating, and a high minimum on a low key mostly keeps the queue empty.
- Minimum item level: also capped at your own item level.
- Voice chat: add a Discord link or similar if you want to talk during the run.
- Private: shows the listing only to your guild and friends.
- Faction: groups are cross-realm and cross-faction unless you limit the listing to Alliance or Horde.
Picking Players: What to Check Beyond Rating
Rating shows how high someone has gone, not how they play. Before you invite, check a few more things:
- Best run in this dungeon: a timed +9 here matters more than a high overall rating built in other dungeons.
- Item level close to the rest of the group.
- The Keystone Deserter flag, which marks players who leave keys without voting.
- Group needs: a Bloodlust, a battle resurrection and enough interrupts for the dungeon.
The Raider.IO addon still works in Midnight and shows every applicant's best runs in the tooltip, and the Premade Groups Filter addon hides gold-selling and carry listings. Our best Mythic+ addons guide covers both.
PUG-Friendly Routes
A PUG has no shared plan, so pick a route without risky skips or huge pulls and share it before the key starts. Most groups use Mythic Dungeon Tools for this. Our Mythic+ routes guide links a safe route for every Season 2 dungeon.
PUG Etiquette: Communication, Wipes and Leaving
Most PUG keys are lost to a group falling apart, not to damage. A few habits keep a group together until the last boss:
- Talk before the first pull. Agree on the route, when to use Bloodlust and who kicks which caster. One line in chat is enough.
- Prepare before you activate the key. The timer starts when the keystone is activated, so eat, flask and set up feasts first.
- Stay after the first wipe. An early wipe rarely ends a key, and many groups still time it. Leaving is what bricks it.
- Don't blame one player. A depleted key is almost always several mistakes added up.
- Use /abandon instead of leaving. The vote teleports everyone out and lowers the key by one level with no penalty. Players who leave keys without it get the Keystone Deserter flag in Group Finder.
Once the key has started, the group can't swap anyone in. If a player leaves mid-run, the remaining four either finish or vote to abandon. Our Mythic+ deaths and penalties guide explains how much time each death costs.
When to Move from PUGs to a Static Group
Pugging works up to high keys, but the higher you go, the more a group that already knows the route and the cooldown plan matters. Players pushing well above Keystone Legend usually rely on a network of regular partners. Start small: add the players you timed keys with to your friends list, join a Mythic+ community or Discord, and run with two or three regulars plus pugs. That alone makes your keys far more consistent.
More Guides for Pugging Mythic+
The beginner guide covers your first keys, the rating guide explains what groups see on your profile, and the comps and routes guides help you build and run a group.
Mythic+ PUG FAQ
These are the questions players ask most about Group Finder and pugging in Season 2.
What rating do I need to get invited to a +10?
Groups often look for around 2,560, the rating you have after timing every dungeon at +10, and a timed +9 or +10 in that dungeon.
Why do my applications keep getting declined?
Usually because your rating or best run in that dungeon is below the key, your item level is lower than other applicants, or you carry the Keystone Deserter flag.
Which playstyle should I pick when I list a key?
Learning or Relaxed for keys you are still learning, Competitive when the group should push for time, and Carry Offered only if you are taking newer players through.
What should I write in my application note?
One line with your best time in that dungeon, that you know the route, or what you bring, such as Bloodlust or a battle resurrection.
What happens if someone leaves the key?
No one can join mid-run. The remaining players can finish the dungeon or use /abandon, which lowers the key by one level without a penalty.
How do I hide gold-selling and carry ads?
Set a minimum Mythic+ rating in your search filters, or use the Premade Groups Filter addon.
Do I need the Raider.IO addon in Midnight?
It isn't required, but it still works in patch 12.1.5 and shows every applicant's best runs, which makes picking players much easier.
Update history 1
- Release